The Slash Operator in Python

When Order is Non-Negotiable

---

There are many Python’s built-in functions that only accept arguments by position. This functionality can be coded by using a slash (/) in the function definition. It’s not just for division anymore, folks!

1. Parameters that appear before the slash (/) can only be specified by position.

2. Parameters after the slash (/) can be specified by position or keyword.

At first you might think why would someone want to do so? But there are certain applications where using this way of calling a function makes it more intuitive and easier to maintain.

Image generated using AI

---

Clarity in Mathematical Functions:

For example, consider the following code where we are writing a function which raises a base number to a certain exponent power.

def power(base, exponent):
    return base ** exponent

# Math notation is traditionally position-based
print(power(2, 3))    # Clear and concise: 8
# power(base=2, exponent=3) 

Suppose we want to compute the answer for 2 raised to the power 3:

print(power(2, 3))

to get:

8

which is correct. We can also write this as:

power(exponent=3, base=2)

which would again give use:

8

Now although this is correct, this would be unnecessarily verbose. We have been trained in mathematics to read numbers and equations in a certain way. In mathematics, when we write 2 ³, we don’t say “hey, let’s take the exponent of 3 and apply it to base 2” — that would be weird, right? We say “2 raised to the power of 3.” Here’s how we can make our code just as intuitive. This makes the use of slash useful here:

def power(base, exponent, /):
    return base ** exponent

When we call this function, we would read it as power of 2 raised to 3.

print(power(2, 3))

to get:

8

We could similarly see this for division function also:

def divide_pos(x, y, /):    # The / makes x and y position-only
    return x / y

Beautiful, isn’t it? No awkward power(exponent=3, base=2) allowed here. Mathematics has been doing just fine without keyword arguments for centuries, thank you very much!

---

API Stability: The “Change Your Name, Keep Your Friends” Feature

Position-only arguments allow internal parameter names to change without breaking client code.

Suppose we have the following function:

def plot_point(x, y, /):
    return f"Plotting at {x},{y}"

Later on, if the team decides to rename the parameters to longitude and latitude instead of x and y, respectively, the client code would still work perfectly.

def plot_point(longitude, latitude, /):
    return f"Plotting at {longitude},{latitude}"

The following code would output the same for both the above code:

print(plot_point(10, 20))   

---

Speaking C’s Language

Many of Python’s built-in functions are implemented in C, where keyword arguments don’t exist. The C language looks at Python’s keyword arguments and says “we don’t do that here”?

Position-only arguments provide a natural way to maintain this C-like interface. Consider these built-in functions:

len([1, 2, 3])      

This works, outputing:

3

But the following raises an error:

len(obj=[1, 2, 3])

TypeError: len() takes no keyword arguments

This behavior isn’t arbitrary — it reflects the underlying C implementation where functions have fixed parameter positions. The slash operator helps Python play nice with its C cousins. It’s like a translator that helps Python speak C’s more rigid dialect.

---

Performance Implications: The Speed Demon’s Secret

Want to make your functions run faster? Position-only arguments are like taking the express lane. When a function accepts keyword arguments, Python must maintain a dictionary of parameter names and handle argument matching. Position-only arguments bypass this overhead:

def fast_add(x, y, /):
    return x + y     # Direct mapping to C's add function

def regular_add(x, y):
    return x + y     # Python must process possible keyword arguments

No stops, just pure speed.

---

FFI (Foreign Function Interface) Considerations

When wrapping C libraries, position-only arguments help maintain consistent interfaces. Let’s create a Python class that simulates a C-style interface. In this class, we would create provide the ability to access an element at the specified index and also the possibility to set it:

class CFriendlyArray:
    def __init__(self, size, /):
        self.array = [0] * size  # C would be proud
    
    def set(self, index, value, /):
        self.array[index] = value  # Just like C's array[index] = value
    
    def get(self, index, /):
        return self.array[index]  # C-style array access, minus the segfaults

Now lets try to use it like the C:

arr = CFriendlyArray(5)

This is like initializing an array of size 5 in C:

int arr[5];

Now lets try to set i the value at the 0 position to 10:

arr.set(0, 10)

This is similar to:

arr[0] = 10;

We could also access the element at the 0 position:

print(arr.get(0))

This is quite in line with our C equivalent:

printf("%d", arr[0]);

But the following would fail:

try:
    arr = CFriendlyArray(size=5)
except TypeError as e:
    print(f"\nError creating array: {e}")

try:
    arr.set(index=0, value=10)
except TypeError as e:
    print(f"Error setting value: {e}")

C functions don’t have keyword arguments. The above example helps to showcase how using slash helped in maintaining a direct mapping to C functions. Position-only arguments in Python make the mapping more natural

---

Conclusion

Position-only arguments in Python serve a dual purpose: they provide clean C compatibility and enforce conventional usage patterns. While they might seem restrictive compared to Python’s typically flexible argument passing, they play a crucial role in system interfaces, mathematical functions, and performance-critical code.

Understanding when to use position-only arguments is as important as knowing how to use them. They’re most valuable when:

• Implementing C-compatible interfaces

• Writing mathematical functions

• Optimizing performance-critical code

• Ensuring API stability

As Python continues to evolve, position-only arguments represent an important tool in bridging the gap between Python’s flexibility and the more rigid conventions of systems programming.

Remember: sometimes, being inflexible is a feature, not a bug. The slash operator is Python’s way of saying “this is how we do things here, and we’re sticking to it!” It’s like having a very strict but well-meaning teacher — sometimes their rigidity is exactly what you need to learn the right way.

Now go forth and use your slashes wisely! Just remember: with great position-only arguments comes great responsibility to document your code properly. 😉